Ep 107: This Beautiful Mess (GH)

What does healing from church hurt actually require? In this Greenhouse episode, Brian, Handsome Kyle, and Doc continue the conversation from Episode 106 with Matt Davis. Mattโ€™s story opened up a raw and necessary discussion about church hurt, pastoral burnout, ministry failure, institutional self-protection, and the people who are wounded when church systems value the institution more than the individual. This follow-up conversation asks what comes next. How should we think about pastors? Have we turned the pastoral office into a professional class or a platform role instead of a shepherding role? Can people be deeply formed if they are part of a church where no one really knows them? And why do so many churches have beautiful on-ramps for new people but confusing, painful, or graceless off-ramps for people who are burned out, wounded, or leaving? Brian, Handsome Kyle, and Doc also explore whether the modern sermon has been asked to carry more formative weight than it can bear. Instruction matters, but spiritual formation does not happen through instruction alone. People need time, habits, community, intimacy, and spaces where they can confess, wrestle, suffer, wait, and be known.

BY Brian Fisher

September 17, 2024

church hurt and healing

SHARE THIS PODCAST

Search

Ut dapibus massa eu libero molestie, eu vulputate risus dapibus. Phasellus dictum mi quis laoreet bibendum. Nunc sit amet venenatis massa. Nullam vel urna magna. Nulla porttitor lorem vel tristique commodo. Sed malesuada sagittis luctus. Praesent faucibus nulla vel turpis cursus blandit. Donec vitae lectus vel ex volutpat aliquam.

Kingdom of God
Soil and Roots
Ep 107: This Beautiful Mess (GH)
Loading
/

Healing from Church Hurt

Sometimes our institutional churches provide comfort, care, instruction, and community. And sometimes not.  Much like the human person, our Christian communities are beautiful messes.

The guys jump back into the Greenhouse to expand on Brianโ€™s conversation with ex-mega church pastor Matt Davis and our exploration of The Formation Gap.ย  Dr. Tim guides the conversation through some challenging questions:

  • What is the role of the modern pastor today, and does it reflect a biblical shepherd?
  • Are mega-churches helpful for spiritual formation? Are they necessary and good?
  • We hear news of near-constant scandals and abuses of power in Christian institutions.ย  How do deep disciples evaluate and process these power structures in light of Christ as a suffering servant?

Join us for this thoughtful, thought-provoking dialogue about our journey to become more like Jesus in modern Christian institutions.

This episode continues the discussion from Ep 106.

Continue the Journey

Season Summary Page

Related article

ICON
Is God good

Doubting Godโ€™s Goodness (GH) | Ep 143

What do we do when we find ourselves doubting Godโ€™s goodness?

In this Greenhouse episode, Brian and Doc continue the conversation from Episode 142 by exploring one of the most difficult tensions in deep discipleship: how to affirm Godโ€™s goodness while honestly grieving the pain, injustice, and suffering of the world. Doc brings his own struggle into the conversation, naming the friction between experiencing Godโ€™s kindness in his own life and seeing deep suffering in the lives of others.

This episode is not a philosophical defense of Godโ€™s goodness. It is a conversation about lament, authenticity, doubt, secure attachment, and the kind of community where people can bring their rawest questions without being rushed, corrected, or shamed. Brian and Doc explore why modern church culture often struggles with lament, why easy answers can fail the heart, and why the deeper question beneath โ€œIs God good?โ€ may be a cry for withness.

Read more
Is God good

Ep 142: Is God Good? The Hidden Doubt Many of Us Carry

Is God good, and do our hearts actually experience Him that way?

In Episode 142, Brian continues Season 7, The Good Life, by exploring one of the most powerful hidden ideas many followers of Jesus carry: the suspicion that God may not actually be good. We may consciously affirm Godโ€™s goodness, love, mercy, and faithfulness, yet our lived experience can tell another story.

Drawing from the Soil & Roots distinction between beliefs and ideas, Brian explores how hidden assumptions about God are formed through suffering, disappointment, family systems, trauma, illness, and repeated experiences. The episode considers how distrust of Godโ€™s goodness often shows up through the Eight Indicators: control, anxiety, resentment toward reality, and difficulty receiving love.

Read more
what is God like

Ep 141: The Most Important Thing About Us: Our Hidden Ideas About God (GH)

What if your view of God shapes everything?

In this Greenhouse episode, Brian and Doc continue the conversation from Episode 140 on what God is really like and why our deepest ideas of God matter so much. Season 7, Deep Calls to Deep, is exploring how we become people of depth โ€” people who are increasingly attuned to God, others, themselves, and the world.

The conversation begins with Richard Fosterโ€™s claim that the world does not need more talented or intelligent people as much as it needs deep people. But becoming deep is not always safe, comfortable, or tidy. The inward journey can involve pruning, tearing, fire, pain, and the slow process of being unmade and remade by Godโ€™s goodness.

Brian and Doc then explore how our view of God becomes the root system beneath nearly every other view we hold. Our theology shapes our philosophy, our politics, our view of creation, our understanding of the sacred and secular, and even how we think about suffering, the church, and the Bible.

Read more